Proteinisn’t just for bodybuilders.

And that’s where protein powders come in.

Read on to find out which powdered protein came out on top.

protein powder scoop

Shutterstock

How We Graded Them

Here are the four metrics we used to determine each protein powder’s final grade.

Eat This, Not That!

The shake’s consistency was quite smooth and far from gritty.

Quest Vanilla Milkshake

There are way better versions out there and you’ll get to them in a jiffy.

My “this will be fun” experience quickly and darkly turned into a much scarier moment.

No, this does not taste like chocolate.

gold standard whey

No, this does not taste like peanut butter.

What it does taste like is pulverized produce and crushed expectations.

So if you’re into the whole holding-a-green-shake-because-it-looks-cool vibe, then you’ll probably appreciate the Hulk-hued blend.

amazing grass protein superfood

Sadly, the powder’s grainy texture wasn’t as debatably impressive as its color.

(After all, it does contain organic marine algae and spirulina.)

Taste:Excessively sweet and long-lasting stevia aftertaste.

Vega One shake French Vanilla

Once more liquid was added, it was delightfully smooth.

Taste:This is where Garden of Life lost us.

In addition to that, this shake was oddly saltier than a handful of pretzels.

Orgain Organic Protein Sweet Vanilla Bean

Plus, the taste is significantly more tolerable than other whey-based powders.

Shaking it up with some soymilk improved the consistency by leaps and bounds.

The natural, low-glycemic coconut sugar adds a mild sweetness without an unpalatable aftertaste.

Garden of Life Sport Chocolate

Say Aloha to our favorite protein powder!

Designer Whey French Vanilla

Sunwarrior Protein Powder Classic Chocolate

ALOHA Chocolate protein powder