Fall has officially flung, there’s a crispness to the air, and the days are getting shorter.
It can only mean one thing: pumpkin pie season is upon us.
It’s also that time of year when everyoneincludingMartha Stewarthas an opinion about it.
Photo: Traceyaphotos2/Shutterstock
No matter where you stand on pumpkin spice, there’s no denying the saccharine Americana of pumpkin pie.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville, S.C.
“Nothing screams ‘grandma’ like a pumpkin pie!”
So says Leslie Rohland, chef of several ventures in Bluffton, S.C., includingThe Juice HiveandThe Cottage Cafe.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Sofra Bakery & Cafe Cambridge, Mass.
Skewing contemporary, Valerie Nin opts for the sesame caramel pumpkin pie fromSofra Bakery & Cafein Cambridge, Mass.
Which Grocery Chain Has the Most Delicious Pre-Made Pumpkin Pie This Year?
Gracious Bakery/Facebook
Urth Caffe Los Angeles
Ben Sidell likes the “thick buttery crust” atUrth Caffe.
Honeycomb Hamilton, Mass.
When it comes to holiday cravings, Marissa Rossi heads toHoneycombin Hamilton, Mass.
Sofra Bakery & Cafe/Facebook
“The pies are baked fresh and never frozen.
While you’re there grab a sandwich or a box of pastries.
Everything there is yummy!”
Urth Caffé
It’s definitely a guilty pleasure, but just be sure to let Mom down easy."
So raves D’Andre Carter, chef and owner ofSoul & Smokein Chicago.
“That perfectly flaky and delicious crust satisfies every time.
honeycombhamilton/Instagram
And when cravings for old-fashioned pumpkin pie arise, it’s off toFlying Saucer Pie Company.
“Their pumpkin pie is absolutely unpretentious and presented in the most traditional form possible,” says Harneja.
It is a family-owned bakery from 1967, and they have always believed in no-frill approach to pies.
Milk Bar
A simple, nostalgic, and freshly baked pumpkin pie is all you need during fall season.
Better than anyone else.”
“One thing I’m particular about is avoiding preservatives and stabilizers.
Prairie Grass Cafe/Facebook
The version sliced and served atSidney Street Cafein St. Louis.
“It’s a spin on a classic,” she says.
“This dessert is not too sweet, with warm spice notes that shout fall.
Flour Bakery+Cafe/Facebook
Hudson Valley Bakery Kingston, N.Y. We’ve been known to order a slice of every variety of their menu whenever we visit!”
“The filling is velvety and the crust is buttery and perfectly crimped,” says Taylor.
“Costco pumpkin pie, and all pies, are elite!”
Petee’s Pie Company
he raves, calling them “extremely affordable,” delicious, and consistent.
Flying Saucer Pie Company/Instagram
Hoosier Mama Pie Company
eatpoppie/Instagram
sidneystcafe/Instagram
salingersorchard/Instagram
Photo: Hudson Valley Bakery/Facebook
nobieshtx/Instagram
The Able Baker
Costco / Facebook
