Many customers have grown to appreciate Chicken Bakes for their convenience and"tasty"flavor.

But do the frozen versionstasteas good as the fresh ones?

I set out to answer that question for by comparing the two in a taste test.

Costco Chicken Bake box on red and yellow background

Photo: Costco. Design: Eat This, Not That!

They say the new version is smaller, contains less filling, and is overall less satisfying.

“They’re still good.

The crust had been baked super well-done and was covered in a generous layer of caramelized cheese.

Costco food court and frozen Chicken Bakes on wooden cutting board

Zoe Strozewski for Eat This, Not That!

The interior had a decent amount of filling, but looked somewhat dry.

It weighed in at 330 grams on my kitchen scale.

The taste:Comforting and decently tasty, but not without its flaws.

Costco food court Chicken Bake

Zoe Strozewski for Eat This, Not That!

On the other hand, the texture of the filling left a little to be desired.

The chicken was chopped sort of finely.

I would have much preferred big, juicy pieces of poultry.

Kirkland Signature Chicken Bake, frozen

Zoe Strozewski for Eat This, Not That!

The filling was also slightly dry and had more of a goopy than saucy feel to it.

Overall, the food court Chicken Bake is enjoyable yet far from perfect.

I wouldn’t necessarily expect anything better than this for just $3.99.

Costco Chicken Bakes cross sections

Zoe Strozewski for Eat This, Not That!

Unlike the food court iteration, the frozen variety had bits of green onion distributed throughout the filling.

The taste:This frozen version fell short in almost every way.

But I still couldn’t stomach more than a couple of bites.

Why TrustEat This, Not That!