But not even the most popular products are guaranteed to go unscathed in the court of public opinion.

“The flavor wasn’t quite right.

The chocolate didn’t seem to go well with the peanut butter.

costco

Sheila Fitzgerald / Shutterstock

The consistency was more like a frosting than a pie filling.

“Compared to the other bakery options, it’s a solid ‘meh,'” anothersaid.

Will not buy again.

Costco chocolate peanut butter pies

Photo: Chris Shott, Eat This, Not That!

other Costco members haven’t had the opportunity to try it at all.