This combo is the very definition of a warm and cozy dessert.

So, I wanted to know which store has the freshest, best-tasting rendition.

The crust had a crumbly, graham cracker look to it, which I liked.

Costco vs. Sam’s Club: Pumpkin Pie Taste Test

Photos by Ronnie Koenig

The filling tasted like straight-up pumpkin puree.

The value:At $5.99 for a nearly 12-inch pie this was a great value.

This Thanksgiving, you’ll want Sam' Club’s pumpkin pie on your holiday table.

Pumpkin pie from Costco

Photo: Ronnie Koenig for Eat This, Not That!

costco pumpkin pie

Ronnie Koenig

Pumpkin pie from Sam’s Club

Ronnie Koenig for Eat This, Not That!

sam’s club pumpkin pie

Ronnie Koenig