This content references scientific studies and academic research, and is fact-checked to ensure accuracy.
Our teamof licensed nutritionists and dietitians strives to be objective, unbiased, and honest.
“Skippy is better,” one personcommented.
Shutterstock
“Skippy and Jif tastes like happy childhood,“addedanother.
However, others noted that the popular brand has more sugar and is less natural than others.
Jif
Another OG peanut butter that several Redditors swear is the best?
Shutterstock
“Jif is my jam,” someonesays.
“Jiff for life,” addsanother.
Almond butter, with many supporting the Kirkland brand.
Shutterstock
“I have moved to the almond butter.
PB is good, AB better IMO,” one personwrites.
Homemade Peanut Butter
Some prefer making their own.
Costco
“Have you tried making your own?
“Go to Mom’s Organic Market and grind some fresh peanut butter into a to-go container.
“Mom’s freshly ground peanut butter is incredible.
Shutterstock
It comes out warm from the grinder and you never need to spend time mixing it.
“The Smuckers natural peanut butter tastes better,” another fanstated.
Trader Joe’s
Trader Joe’s, especially the crunchy variety, is another crowd-pleaser.
Shutterstock
“I also appreciate that Trader Joe’s also sells unsalted peanut butter.
Just peanut butter without palm oil or salt.
It’s the best!
Trader Joe’s
I am fan of Costco and wish they would also sell unsalted peanut butter,” anothersays.
“We buy the Adams chunky stuff instead,” one Redditorcommented.
(And the only ingredients are peanuts and salt!)
Adams Natural Peanut Butter
TBH I think if Addams weren’t available I’d go with the Kirkland peanut butter,” anotheradded.
“I usually buy Teddie’s from Costco … same ingredients,” onesays.
People noted the superior texture and taste.
Teddie Natural Peanut Butter
Kirkland (Costco’s brand)
Overall, Kirkland Organic Creamy Peanut Butter took top honors.
“There is no substitute for their PB,” the original posterdeclared.
“I’m obsessed with this peanut butter,“agreedanother.
Costco
One of the main reasons people swear by it is that it is the most natural.
“Kirkland is just peanuts and sea salts.
Other ‘natural’ brands add palm oil, sugar, and molasses.
“I love it so much.
It has become the baseline for all other peanut butter to be compared against,” onesays.6254a4d1642c605c54bf1cab17d50f1e
