But these detractors haven’t deterred devotees from gobbling up the birds in mind-boggling numbers.

Costcosold 137 million rotisserie chickens in 202320 million more thanin 2022.

Just remember that one person’s idea of a perfect Costco rotisserie chicken may differ from another.

Costco rotisserie chicken on striped red background

Photo: Costco. Design: Eat This, Not That!

An instant judge of getting a bigger chicken."

Those who shop for larger families say these extra-large birds really come in handy.

“For our family of 5, size DOES matter when it comes to affordability.

Costco rotisserie chicken in shopping cart

Zoe Strozewski for Eat This, Not That!

So, I usually look for the biggest one that also looks nice and seasoned,” a Redditorwrote.

Since more browning means more flavor, customers alsorecommendchoosing chickens cooked to a deeper color for the best taste.

I feel they are juicer.

Line of Costco rotisserie chickens

Zoe Strozewski for Eat This, Not That!

I find the darker ones are much drier."

Just a little patience can get you first pick of the batch.

“If I see the worker is about to bring out a new batch, I will wait.

Mid-sized Costco rotisserie chicken

Zoe Strozewski for Eat This, Not That!

Refraining from grabbing the largest chickens you could find, however, could help you avoid any underdone birds.

Instead, shoppers suggest opting for a bird that’s more middle of the pack in terms of size.

Now I go for midsize,” a Redditorshared.

Costco rotisserie chickens lined up on shelves

Zoe Strozewski for Eat This, Not That!

So I choose a medium sized bird with darker skin."

rotisserie chicken costco

calimedia / Shutterstock

Costco rotisserie chicken shelves

Zoe Strozewski for Eat This, Not That!