For card-carrying members, Costco is far more than just a grocery store.
Throughout 2024, several finds became especially popular with Costco shoppers, garnering rave reviews and flying off shelves.
Look no further than the AmyluCaramelized Onion & Aged White Cheddar Chicken Burgerssold at Costco.
Photos: Costco, oasisamuel / Shutterstock. Design: Eat This, Not That!
“They are the best.
Ingredients are best in class,” a Redditorsaidof the burgers.
“Absolutely amazing,” anothercommented.
Costco
One fan even went so far as to declare the burgers their"favorite Costco buy."
It’s a fierce adoration that has stood the test of time.
Some even consider them an essential Costco buy.
Costco
“Everybody talks about the chicken and the pizza, but these are the flagship of Costco!”
a shopperwroteof the Aussie Bites on Reddit earlier this year.
“I’ll cancel my membership if they stop selling them,” anotherwrote.
Photo: Costco
Each box also comes with a carving stand, knife, and slicing instructions.
In addition to looking pretty impressive, customers say the charcuterie tastes pretty darn good as well.
“I was skeptical because I thought the meat must be trash but it’s amazing.
Costco
“We buy it every year for our NYE party.
Our guests now expect it,” another Redditorwrote.
In a Reddit discussion earlier this year, some evensaid that the frozen pie brand rivals real-deal pizza restaurants.
Costco
Glad they still had them in stock when I went back yesterday.
Tastes just like from a restaurant,” a fan raved onReddit.
“My wife and I had this tonight and both really enjoyed it,” anotherwrote.
Costco
“Not sweet, not too acidic.
I hope this stays a while.”
“I need two,” a Redditorwrote.
Beecher’s Handmade Cheese
“I immediately went to purchase and it is now sold out.
My wife would have loved it.
Oh well,” a Redditorlamented.
Photo: Costco / Facebook
It’s then aged for nine months in Kentucky bourbon barrels.
When they finallyreturned to shelvesthis fall, the shopper response was just as enthusiastic.
“Awesome in the air fryer!”
Costco
Anotherwrotethat it “might be our new favorite prepared meal.”
In a Reddit thread, one fan evendeclaredthem the “best Costco cookie ever made.”
“They need to be available year-round,” a fellow shoppercommented.
Photo: Costco
“I’ll take three, and then line them up on my tiny coffee table,” anotherwrote.
They’re also one of the most unique offerings within Costco’s grocery selection.
The item starts with freshly frozen grapes that are splashed with lemon juice and coated in sour candy.
Costco / Facebook
Fans have raved that they’re hard to stop eating and really deliver on the “sour” factor.
“I’m a huge fan of these.
“If you like really sour candy, these are the bomb.
Photo: Costco
I can only handle like three to four before I’m done.
But they are nice and sour,” anothersaid.
It wasn’t long after the launch that the glowing reviews began pouring in for the indulgent dessert.
Fruit Riot
“We thought it was delicious, the texture was smooth and creamy.
We also like the graham cracker crust,” a Redditorwrote.
But Trader Joe’s isn’t the only grocery chain to cause a stir with tote bags this year.
Photo: Chris Shott/Eat This, Not That!
“I’m convinced that I do need this bag,” a Redditorjoked.
“It’s so cute,” anothersaid.
The boxes come with a one-year Gold Star membership activation card and are priced at $65.
@costcoguide / TikTok
