In a lifetime as acookie-lover, dozens (if not more!)
of fantastic cookies come and go from the store shelves, for various reasons.
It can be a real heartbreaker!
Shutterstock
Read on to find out which cookies loved us, left us, and aren’t ever coming back.
Then head to your kitchen and enjoy your favoritestore-bought cookie.
You never know, it might be the last time you get to eat it.
RITZ Crackers / Twitter
And for more, don’t miss these15 Classic American Desserts That Deserve a Comeback.
More of a cookie than a cracker, these treats werediscontinued in 2016.
They did make a brief return in 2022, butonly as a giveaway.
Courtesy of Philadelphia
Keebler Magic Middles
These soft shortbread cookies were stuffed with chewy gooey fudge or peanut butter fillings.
There have beenplenty of petitions to bring the Magic back, but none have succeeded yet.
Try this recipe fromTop Secret Recipes.
Courtesy of Instacart
The faces were a little creepy, but not creepy enough to stop them from being a lunchbox staple.
They were discontinued when Keebler bought up the maker, Sunshine.6254a4d1642c605c54bf1cab17d50f1e
Planters P.B.
Crisps
These peanut-shaped cookies with peanut butter creme inside were a peanut butter lovers' dream.
Shutterstock
Despite their popularity,the cookies, which launched in 1992, were gone from store shelves by 1995.
The crunch version seems to have disappeared from store shelves over the past few years, sadly.
Apple Newtons
Fig Newtons still come in multiple flavors, but apple isn’t one of them.
Nabisco/YouTube
Nabisco/YouTube
Shutterstock
Courtesy of PB Crisps Fanatic
Alexandra Filipek
Natali Ploskaya/Shutterstock
Pepperidge Farm/YouTube
Alp Aksoy/Shutterstock
