Why is Crumbl so popular?
More recently, Crumbl has expanded tonon-cookie dessertsas well.
The most popular cookie flavors occasionally make the rounds again.
Crumbl/Facebook
Some favorites pop up seasonally for holidays like St. Patrick’s Day, Halloween, or Shark Week.
Others will re-emerge but with a slight twist on their last iteration.
But which flavors have made the greatest impact among fans?
Crumbl
Here are some of the most beloved Crumbl cookies of all time.
It’s a yellow butter cake cookie dripping in a melt-in-your-mouth buttery glaze, according to the company.
One customer notes onRedditthat the “Lemon Bar tastes EXACTLY like lemon meringue pie.”
Photo: Crumbl / X
Another shared onRedditthat the Lemon Bar Cookie is, in their opinion, “godtier.
It was so good when I got it before.”
OREO Birthday Cake
Birthday Cake cookies are not a new phenomenon at Crumbl.
Photo: Crumbl / Facebook
Basically, if you’re a fan of all things OREO, this cookie is right up your alley.
Multiple Oreo flavors, including the OREO Mallow Sandwich, are memorable for Crumbl customers.
The company has introduced spin-offs inspired by Key Lime Pie, including theCoconut Lime Cookie.
Crumbl
Crumbl even took things a step further in April 2024 with the debut of an actualKey Lime Pie.
Graham Cracker feat.
Teddy Grahams
Several Crumbl flavors take inspiration from other sweet treats, like Teddy Grahams.
Photo: Crumbl / Facebook
TheGraham Cracker featuring Teddy Grahamsdoubles down on the graham cracker flavor in this popular cookie.
A superfan of the Cornbread cookie shared onReddit, “I am a cornbread diehard.
I also feel like cornbread fans are somehow extra obsessed with cornbread (but maybe I’m projecting).
Crumbl
Whether it’s a Pumpkin Spice Latte or Cinnamon Rolls, fall flavors are big business for food brands.
Crumbl combined those two flavors into one cookie: Pumpkin Roll.
As one comment said on Instagram, “It’s my favorite pumpkin cookie I’ve ever had.
Photo: Crumbl / Facebook
just, just do this flavor one more time before the end of the year!!”
Pink Sugar is an OG Crumbl cookie flavor, consisting of just a simple sugar cookie with pink frosting.
It recently returned to the chain’s weekly rotating menu, and fans rejoiced.
Crumbl
Get rid of chocolate chip!”
Another fan shared, “This cookie is the one that got me hooked on Crumbl.”
But as oneRedditorsays, “I absolutely love Pink Sugar.
Photo: Crumbl / Facebook
People need to chill with their hate for it and let us enjoy it.”
The aptly-named flavor is known to make appearances on the menu around Mother’s Day.
One comment on Instagram asks, “When is this cookie coming back!!!?
Photo: Crumbl / Facebook
It’s the only one I’m looking forward to.”
Warms up really well in the microwave, too.
It’s just perfect, and I miss her."
Photo: Crumbl / Facebook
Other banana-inspired variations that have made an appearance on Crumbl’s menu includeBanana Cream Pie.
